Today I deleted a rude comment that an anonymous commenter posted in my previous entry about The Butler Plan:
It’s a fucking retarded plan that will never accomplish anything. White racialists need to stop thinking about controlling territory and start thinking about controlling important social institutions.
I removed it because the anonymous commenter seems to be ignorant that (1) without an ethno-state whites will continue to mix and mix and mix until they virtually dissapear in the melting pot (as happened in Mexico half a millenium after the Spanish Conquest), and (2) ignorant also of the content of the longest entry of this blog, where the belief that “activism” or “a march through the institutions” for the purpose of controlling them was proven quixotic.
Last year Trainspotter (penname) gave us a superb lesson at the comments section of the nationalist site Occidental Dissent. Although Trainspotter had to use more than 30,000 words to convey his point to the OD commentariat, he himself boiled down the crux of his argument to a mere 390 words.
The following abstract of that long-winded entry explains why “controlling important social institutions” to form an ethno-state and thus save Caucasians goes beyond the pale for the current zeitgeist; and why, I would add, we must look for more unconventional ways to avoid extinction (such as The Butler Plan).
1. There are well over 100 million non-whites in this country [the U.S.]. Expelling them would be an enormous task, requiring tremendous strife and tears. Normal, sentient human beings understand this. People do not take drastic steps unless they are convinced that they are necessary. They will exhaust other alternatives first. This is normal and natural.
2. Even if you say, “Well, fine, we won’t expel 100 millions non-whites from the country. We’ll break away and form our own country instead, where not nearly so many people will be affected” [this is the Butler Plan]. Doesn’t matter. Functionally, it’s the same as option 1. As long as ZOG is powerful, it’s not letting us go peacefully, no matter what. We aren’t allowed to have an all white pizza parlor, much less an all white nation. As long as ZOG is strong, it would take enormous suffering and pain to create an all-white homeland, even a small one. We can focus on fairness, and try to create a homeland where it will displace the fewest people. Doesn’t matter. Our opponents aren’t interested in fairness. They want us dead.
So we’re back to struggle and strife, tears and suffering. Normal whites understand this, at least implicitly. They know the System would do whatever it could to destroy us, and that this would be true no matter how reasonable our proposals. See again point number 1: People do not take drastic steps unless they are convinced that they are necessary. They will exhaust other alternatives first. This is normal and natural. In the only context that they know, any effort to save whites from destruction would be considered drastic.
3. As the result of the above, white nationalists appear to normal people to be offering a solution that will end in nothing but tears. It doesn’t even matter what the particular solution is: normal whites know that the System will oppose us no matter what. I’m shocked, shocked that more don’t sign up [doing quixotic activism — sarcasm]. Truly amazing.
In short, you can’t offer a drastic solution without first convincing significant numbers/elements that it is necessary, that more moderate solutions won’t work. So what do you advocate, Hunter? Don’t convince anybody, intellectuals are a waste of time.
Sounds like a winning formula to me. Anyone that doesn’t understand the above points is beyond hope, and should switch over to World of Warcraft post-haste.